The Try-Fail Cycle

Characters earn their success. They try, fail, learn something from the failure and try again. Two or three cycles before the win, each failure teaching something, is what makes the win believable.

Opens Shiro with this structure on your Board. Free, in your browser.

The Parts of a Scene

Told Along Robinson Crusoe’s first boat (Daniel Defoe, 1719). One book, beat by beat.

  1. Try

    The character tries to solve the problem.

    Crusoe fells a great cedar and spends months hollowing it into a canoe big enough to carry twenty-six men.

  2. Fail

    It does not work, or works and makes things worse.

    It lies a hundred yards from the water, and he cannot move it an inch.

  3. Learn

    What the failure teaches them.

    He sees the folly of starting work before counting the cost, and of a boat built too far from the sea.

  4. Try again

    A new attempt, changed by what they learned.

    He builds a smaller canoe near a creek, and digs a channel to float it.

Where It Comes From

The name spread among genre writers through teachers such as Brandon Sanderson and the Writing Excuses podcast. The pattern is as old as folk tales, where the youngest brother succeeds on the third try.

When to Use It

Use it inside a scene, across a few chapters, or as the spine of a subplot. It fixes a lead who solves problems too easily. Fairy tales often run three cycles: Goldilocks and her three bowls, beds and chairs.

In Shiro

Set it as your book’s scene structure and each scene’s drawer has four slots, try to try again, which you can fill in or ignore. A scene can also use another scene structure than the book’s.

The Questions People Ask

How many times should a character fail?

Usually two or three times on a big goal before succeeding. Each failure should be for a different reason, so the character learns something new each time.

What is a yes-but and a no-and?

Two ways to end a try. Yes, but: it works, and creates a new problem. No, and: it fails, and makes things worse. Both keep the story moving.

Shiro isn’t affiliated with the authors or publishers named here. Book and method names belong to their owners and are used only to say what we’re talking about.

Last revised November 2026.

And So the Writer, Having Read This Far Down a Website About Writing, Opened a Blank Page at Last.